Thursday, April 19, 2012

My MJD Dilema - opinions welcome

So in my final Ultimate Weekend purchase I pulled MJD (as well as Dockett) - and I was pretty stoked. I then found Mathis for 35k BIN and thought - wow - I'm well on my way to that Jags collection I thought I'd never get (I pulled a bunch of others this weekend).

Now, my dilema. From what I'm seeing on the AH - I can get a LOT for Jones-Drew - almost as much as the entire Jags collection is worth. On the one hand - there's part of me that likes "completing" things and being so close to easily completing the Jags collection is enticing. On the other hand, giving up these players to get 100K and a 90 Fred Taylor seems "not worth it" - and perhaps I could use that money to complete another collection instead that has a better reward (i.e., the Lions which I'm also close on).

What do you guys think? Should I sell MJD? What's been "going rate" on him lately (I'm on 360)?

Thanks in advance.|||the Roy Williams you get for the Lions isnt really worth it lol Especially since you have to give up Megatron for him|||dont try to sell him on AH, if you want coins throw him in the collection 100k for that will be more than what you can sell him for on there. although you might be able to sell him on here to someone for more than 100k|||


So in my final Ultimate Weekend purchase I pulled MJD (as well as Dockett) - and I was pretty stoked. I then found Mathis for 35k BIN and thought - wow - I'm well on my way to that Jags collection I thought I'd never get (I pulled a bunch of others this weekend).

Now, my dilema. From what I'm seeing on the AH - I can get a LOT for Jones-Drew - almost as much as the entire Jags collection is worth. On the one hand - there's part of me that likes "completing" things and being so close to easily completing the Jags collection is enticing. On the other hand, giving up these players to get 100K and a 90 Fred Taylor seems "not worth it" - and perhaps I could use that money to complete another collection instead that has a better reward (i.e., the Lions which I'm also close on).

What do you guys think? Should I sell MJD? What's been "going rate" on him lately (I'm on 360)?

Thanks in advance.

At the beginning of the weekend you could get a lot for him. Buts that before a bunch of people pulled him. So if you want to max your coins out, you probably are going to need to sit on him for a while. He is needed for the AFC HB reward is why his value spiked, but you also have to figure that after the initial rush there are always going to be more MJDs out there than gold CJs.

Several of us like Fred Taylor, but others not so much, so its a hard call. MJD is a great back to just play with as well...don't forget that. Plus its positive chem to start both him and Mathis at the same time. You can always play with them now and collect or sell them later.

I'm a Jags fan so I had to get two MJDs...one to collect for Freddie T and the other to continue to play. If I ever get gold CJ I will for sure turn him into elite MJD.

If you were just going to throw him on the AH for max BIN, thats only 78k-10k posting fee...so 68k != 100k+Fred T. If you mean to zero the bid out to get over max, you have to use two people/360s to knock the bid back and forth to raise it (and trust me thats super annoying both to the people doing it and the people bidding). Otherwise you are just looking at 2-3k over the max (and thats totally not worth the trouble).|||Thanks everyone for the feedback - appreciate it. Gotta figure out what I want to do - but may just sit on him for now. One thing I didn't mention is that I have the Rookie CJ right now - and use him almost exclusively at RB (since he's cheap to reload contracts and a beast to use) - so I don't really use any other RB's now (just sold BCA Mendenhall and have J Stewart on my bench).

I may just try starting MJD to see how he fits my style and figure it out from there.|||Thanks everyone for the feedback - appreciate it. Gotta figure out what I want to do - but may just sit on him for now. One thing I didn't mention is that I have the Rookie CJ right now - and use him almost exclusively at RB (since he's cheap to reload contracts and a beast to use) - so I don't really use any other RB's now (just sold BCA Mendenhall and have J Stewart on my bench).

I may just try starting MJD to see how he fits my style and figure it out from there.

No comments:

Post a Comment